Politicians, Slavery Extension, and the Coming of the Civil War

Partisan Politics and the Path to the Civil War

The American Civil War was not simply the result of conflicting economic systems or moral objections to slavery, as commonly believed. According to leading historian Michael F. Holt, the catalysts for this pivotal moment in the nation's history were, in fact, short-sighted partisan politics. In his brilliant and concise book, Holt distills a lifetime of scholarship to present a disturbingly contemporary explanation for the events that led to secession and war.

Holt's analysis challenges the conventional wisdom that the Civil War arose from irreconcilable differences between the North and South. Instead, he argues that politicians in Washington, particularly members of Congress, recognized the partisan value of the emotionally charged and largely illusory issue of slavery's westward expansion. Driven by the pursuit of reelection and the settling of political scores, these politicians consistently prioritized their own narrow interests over the preservation of sectional comity.

Despite the widespread belief (held in both the North and South) that slavery could never thrive in the areas that sparked the most contentious debates from 1845 to 1861 – the Mexican Cession, Oregon, and Kansas – the political class in the nation's capital exploited these issues for their own gain. Their actions, driven by short-term political calculations, inexorably dragged the country towards disunion and, ultimately, war.

The Fate of Their Country, which includes select speeches by Abraham Lincoln and others, challenges readers to reconsider a seminal moment in American history. Holt's analysis presents a disturbing parallel to the partisan dysfunction that continues to plague the modern political landscape, inviting us to reflect on the consequences of prioritizing partisan interests over the greater good of the nation.

Through his meticulous research and insightful analysis, Holt demonstrates that the Civil War was not an inevitable clash of irreconcilable economic or moral forces, but rather the tragic result of the short-sightedness and self-interest of the political elite. By rethinking the causes of this pivotal event, The Fate of Their Country encourages us to confront the enduring relevance of Holt's findings and consider the lessons they hold for the ongoing struggle to maintain a functional and unified democracy.

product information: